REVIEW: “We All Want Impossible Things” by Catherine Newman

“I would give anything to keep you,” I say through the sob that’s gathering in my throat, and she says, “I know you would. I would give anything to stay.”

Ash

SPOILER-FREE PLOT

Edi has been Ash’s best friend since childhood. Effectively, Edi is one of the greatest loves of Ash’s life. They have, and will always be inseperable – even now that Edi is on hospice with advanced ovarian cancer.

This is a story of their friendship.


READ THIS IF:

  • You’re in the mood for a short, impactful, soul-touching read.
  • You’ve ever lost a loved one — and you’re emotionally ready to read literature that centers around loss.

MY THOUGHTS:

This will probably end up being one of my favorite books of all time.

I will also never be able to read it again.

Someone described this book to me as : “It’ll make you cry and laugh at the same time” and that couldn’t be more true.

The emotions it stirred in me by the near-perfect parallels it created with my own experience with my mother-in-law in hospice genuinely hurt at times – but it also made me cry with laughter and joy.

I respect Catherine Newman so much. She has given me, and every grieving reader, the warmest, sweetest, most selfless hug. If there was ever a book about personal loss worth reading – it’s this one.

This novel is a love letter to anyone who has lost a loved one.

Its creation is an act of compassion and humanity.

I adored it.

I absolutely freaking adored it.

I will forever picture this book with heart eyes, sprinkled with glitter.


CASTING

Mila Kunis
Ash
Natalie Portman
Edi
Ashton Kutcher
Honey
Joe Manganiello
Jude
John Krasinski
Jonah
Kaitlyn Dever
Belle

TOP SONGS

Favorite Moment: Party + Thai Takeout in Hospice